What's killing the music industry? Auto-Tune? The Internet? American Idol? All of the above?

Categories: Lists

The music industry has been marked for death for a long time now, but amazingly, nobody has managed to come up with a concrete reason as to why. Sure, it's easy to assign blame, but the real reason the music is dying is still a mystery to most people in the industry. Thankfully, plenty of stars have weighed in on the subject, and most of their theories are amazingly similar.

5. Rick Rubin
In an interview with Time magazine, Rick Rubin blames the dissolution of the industry on pitch-correction technology. "Right now," he said, "if you listen to pop, everything is in perfect pitch, perfect time and perfect tune. That's how ubiquitous Auto-Tune is." His argument is actually pretty solid, as a startling amount of pop bands these days either use Auto-Tune live, or worse, lip-sync their entire set. It also creates a homogenized sound. Whether that's T-Pain purposeful bad-singing to get a particular sound, or the less noticeable use on something like a Lady Gaga record, what comes out of the industry is so goddamn perfect that nobody can really love it, because it was made by a machine.

4. Bon Jovi
According to Bon Jovi (who, notably, had one of the largest revenue generating tours last year), it wasn't Napster founders Shawn Fanning and Sean Parker that killed the industry, it was Steve Jobs -- as in, Steve Jobs personally killed the music industry by inventing the iPod and iTunes. While many will argue it actually helped reinvigorate people's love for music, the industry part has certainly dissolved. In an interview with The Sunday Times Magazine, Bon Jovi said, "Kids today have missed the whole experience of putting the headphones on, turning it up to ten, holding the jacket, closing their eyes and getting lost in an album, and the beauty of taking your allowance money and making a decision based on a jacket." It's true: kids being educated consumers and not buying a Yes record because it has a sweet fucking painting on it, is certainly a major problem these days.

3. Usher
In an interview with the Guardian last year, Usher, just weeks after his appearance on the show, blasted American Idol. "The true art form of music is being lost," he noted, "because it seems so easy that everyone can do it and that it can happen overnight. Television is a lie." His point is confirmed nearly every single season as the winners go on to do jack shit. It is, however, an interesting paradox when you consider Rick Rubin's theory. American Idol is about finding "real" singing talent and turning them into a star. Usher continues, "The reason why great singers cannot exist in this time is maybe because they're not being properly managed, and maybe they don't understand the full gamut of what being an entertainer is." Wait, is he saying that pop stars should be able to sing AND dance? Crazy talk!

2. Prince
Our top two quotes come from two people who both believe the Internet killed the music industry, but who have varying reasons as to why. Prince actually believes the Internet is over, which is why he released his last record via an insert in a newspaper (another industry which is also thriving, we hear). His exact quote in the Mirror was, "The Internet's completely over. I don't see why I should give my music to iTunes or anyone else... The Internet's like MTV. At one time MTV was hip, and suddenly it became outdated." That's true, MTV isn't hip and it did became outdated -- BECAUSE OF THE INTERNET. Who needs MTV when you have YouTube -- in fact, YouTube (which is on the Internet, in case you weren't aware) is often credited as the driving force for making music videos popular again.

1. John Mellencamp
John Mellencamp also believes the Internet killed the music industry, but in an interview with Reutars, the aging, apparently senile rock star stated, "I think the Internet is the most dangerous thing invented since the atomic bomb. It's destroyed the music business. It's going to destroy the movie business." While that statement is, you know, pretty hip for a 112-year-old like Mellencamp, his jumping on the bandwagon didn't stop there, he went on to say that rock would soon die, just like big band music did, ignoring the fact that people actually, you know, like rock music.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

you article sounds ignorant.

Oskar Ned Kirby
Oskar Ned Kirby

Actually Cougar Mellenbrain's lousy music is why people turn off to him. You ever seen him live? I made the mistake once in Boston. Terrible. He just goes through motions. I actually agree with what Bon Jovi and Usher said. I really miss discovering music from how the LP jacket looks and found some of my FAVE all time bands from YES to ZAPPA just because I liked the jacket. And Usher is right too; American Idol is why Terrorists target America. What a complete lack of culture that trash heep represents.

The Silver Conductor
The Silver Conductor

Wow! Usher come on man you still did the show because you or someone in your camp said dude it's the most watched show on television, I honestly feel he thought about the K.West mike grab and it's effect on people saying so uncool man. The Internet is here to stay. Prince might think it's over,but like all other things we all have opinions. John M, what are you thinking? can you say Napster? let me hear you, FREE DOWNLOADS is what's killing the industry.I The Silver Conductor believe the Internet is the best thing since gum as far as musicians getting to the musical promise land, with social media there has been no better time or level playing field for us to take advantage of artistic freedom, making executive personal choice decisions from cover design to publicity photos, we are finally in charge of our own destiny. I worked with Earth, Wind & Fire for 3 years and have seen some very drastic changes in the industry, but we artists have to use what is there for us now because of those changes.So with that being said, check me out @ www.thesilverconductor.com , Facebook, Twitter, itunes, all of these channels are the future and the future is now. Know who loves you always, The Silver Conductorp.s. "Change Up" the single on itunes check it Now! Go! Go Now!

Now Trending

Denver Concert Tickets

From the Vault