Death to the brown bags: school lunches vs. homemade, a fight to the finish

lunch lede.jpg
Is the concept of students bringing lunch from home dying a hideous death -- just like live social interaction and Gilbert Gottfried's career? At Little Village Academy on Chicago's west side, students are not allowed to bring lunches from home unless they have a medical excuse, so they have two choices: eat what the school serves, or eat...well, you know the rest.

This school's rule is sparking a flavorful debate about infringement of parents' rights, whether or not a Coke and flaming hot chips are a viable lunch option, and how crappy school lunches really are these days. In the interest of ongoing culinary and philosophical debate, we've created a list of three pros and three cons each about brown bag versus plastic lunch plates, and no tater tots will be left behind.

she ra lunch box.jpg
Sentimental old fart alert...
Homemade lunch pros:

3. Endless possibilities.

If your kid wants a pineapple/anchovy/jalapeno wrap with a side of marinara sauce and a handful of beef jerky for lunch, then you can throw all this in a Ziploc bag and guarantee your offspring will have a great lunch...with no chance in hell of trading anything for a Nutty Bar.

2. The badass lunch box to show off.

You bought the pink plastic She-Ra Princess of Power lunch box for two dollars on eBay, and it even came with the matching Thermos. And free shipping. Living vicariously through your kid: priceless.

healthy school-lunch.jpg
You wish your little mutant grubbers would eat this.

1. Super Mommy/Daddy props.

Nothing tells the other kids' parents that you are better than they are than sending your precious spawn off to school with a designer bento box filled with bits of jicama artfully cut into the shapes of the fifty states and Puerto Rico.

Homemade lunch cons:

3. Getting up is hard to do.

Waking your ass up in the a.m. to slap together your child's mid-day meal is more than your Ambien-laced brain should have to process, so letting the fruit of your loins eat barbecued chips for lunch seems like a much better way to show you really care.

junk lunch.jpg
This is what your kids want for lunch every single day.

2. Whittling down the shopping list.

Packing your grocery cart with diet lychee-flavored vitamin water and chocolate-covered cherry Yoplait light yogurt takes enough time away from your yoga classes and Judge Judy; forget grabbing grape jelly and goldfish crackers.Why not let the nanny relax and just hand your shortie a Visa check card for his afternoon repast?

1. Kids don't like healthy food.

Okay, maybe some kids do like a sack full of carrot sticks and non-fat ranch dressing and a to-go packet of Crystal Light for their triple-filtered bottled water; parents who don't live in Boulder are probably aware that their little sperm blossoms want to mainline Hostess cupcakes and Dr. Pepper every single day of their lives, and they won't stop until they are mainlining congealed soft-shell tacos with Fire sauce and cheap beer in college. Let 'em eat the school lunch. At least there's a chance that they'll suck up some corn with that pool of melted margarine next to the rectangular slab of ersatz pizza.

smoking kid.jpg
Parental supervision is overrated.

School lunch pros:

3. Welfare begins at home.

You are broke, so saving up the pennies on the EBT card and packing your child a baggie of WIC-approved dry cereal and a slightly dented can of Vienna sausages is great for rubbing your two dimes together for warmth. Except at the first of the month, because the pickle loaf and white bread sandwich with extra mayo is a treat for your pint-sized tax deductions. There's no shame in being poor, except when you are a kid and the other kids make fun of you, so sign the free-lunch paperwork, let them eat the school lunch every day, and hope none of the other kids find out, because being underprivileged and unpopular in school is just not a gift to give your kids wrapped up in a dollar-store Christmas bow.

2. Sloth should not be one of the seven deadlies.

Shirking parental involvement is not limited to skipping school plays and parent-teacher conferences. As American parents, you should maintain the right and privilege to ignore the needs of your kids as you see fit. You don't wanna know what your kids are eating any more than you wanna know who they're socializing with or how many cigarettes they've smoked at the bus stop. Whether they're eating Uncrustables and scurvy-promoting piles of tater tots or sparking a skunk-laced blunt at recess, you're better off staying out of it for now. Wait till your kids are adults to interfere with their live; it'll be way more productive then.

mystery meat lunch.jpg
You ate this hogswallop and didn't die.

1. You ate school lunches when you were a kid, and you turned out fine.

School lunches are a time-honored tradition in our culture, just like getting loaded on raspberry vodka at the prom and losing your virginity in the back of a van at a Metallica concert. These trays represent a rite of passage for students, and to deprive them of those little squares of canned pears and red Jell-O would be robbing them of an important cultural milestone.

School lunch cons:

3. Feeding Big Brother's appetite for control.

The government already forces you to pay taxes, buy insurance and refrain from carrying switchblade knives. Now this? The Orwellian powers that be in our federal and state governments have trickled down their influence right into our public schools, and if we start letting the Man tell us we have to feed our kids hoagies with a tossed salad and fruit cup every Thursday then we might as well sit idly by and let them take sex education, art and music classes away, too.

tofu lunch.jpg
This is how we do lunch downtown.

2. Quantity without quality.

A lot of things improve with time -- like wine, exercise equipment and Rob Lowe. School lunches have not improved since the 1970s, and aside from the fact that they are served mostly hot and can be filling if the squab actually eat them, the mass-produced trays of squishy French fries and unconscionably ketchup-flavored sloppy joes are just about as appetizing as licking the inside of a KFC dumpster on a hot day.

1. Your kids are unique--just like everybody else's.

Your kids aren't Highlands Ranch cookie-cutter Aeropostale-wearing suburb brats. Your kids are special, and their creativity and individual personalities must be nurtured and respected. They should not have to be like all the other kids and eat the same glop of overcooked spaghetti served to those Aurora thuglettes, or the salads tossed for the Boulderite granola hippie larvae. Your children are downtown Denver urban sophisticates, and feeding them microbiotic brown-rice broth and spinach-spearmint tofu tartlets will prepare them for an adult life of being exactly like you.

Follow @CafeWestword on Twitter

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

Wow, really? Blunts at the bus stop? Stay out of it for now? And how many references to the fruit of my loins or my little sperm blossom? And my ambien-laced brain can't pack a bag lunch in the am, so leave it to the nanny to hand over the credit card? Whatever good info was in this article was so lost by these pathetically offensive attempts at humor... I need not waste any more time on this than I already have... And what is the Error posting my comment???

kids footwear
kids footwear

There are hundreds of toys in the department store or listed online. Be careful that you don't just get one and put it on your shopping cart without checking out the age recommendations.


this is sick and sad. and also, i would guess, an extension of trying to control food b/c one kid as allergies. Where i went to school, you HAD to bring a lunch; there were no school lunches available. the only thing you could get from the school was your little carton of milk. And both my parents worked, so they obviously found time to make the lunches until such time i made it on my own.

Just another way our kids are fattening up!

But just too sad the demise of the lunch box. There was no great thrill than to get a new lunch box, especially picked out ( although I had a hand-me-down Family Affair lunch box form an older relative for a long time). Only rivaled by picking out the new Trapper Keeper for that school year.



My friend Destany Fenton made a good point after reading this story on FB. I hadn't thought of this one:"School lunch con: portion size remains the same k-12. So mutant teenage boys with appetites the size of baby elephants (and with reason) are expected to thrive on exactly two carrot sricks, half an apple, a 2 oz "meat" patty, and 1/2 a cup of boiled potato flakes.Of course, feeding the entire populas to the standards of the male teenaged animal will not help in the obesity crisis.Oh, and serving nachos with out cheese? That's mean, but it actually happened a few times this year."

Now Trending

From the Vault