Reader: Where's the creativity on Top Chef?

Categories: Cafe Society

Could there be another Hosea Rosenberg in Colorado?
The Top Chef crew came to Denver this week, auditioning chefs for the tenth season of the Bravo show. "We've had auditions before in Denver, but never a proper casting call, and it was time to see what the city's chefs really had to offer," Hunter Braun, Top Chef's senior casting producer, told Lori Midson. "There are a few people who auditioned that I'm really excited about, and while there's no quota, I'd really like to make this trip worthwhile and see a couple of chefs from Colorado on the show."

But Home TV isn't impressed:

As evidenced from this season, creativity is not a requirement. Two of the three finalists (not Paul), didn't exhibit ANY creativity throughout the season, and both failed miserably when it came to team challenges, either failing and blaming others or quitting (restaurant wars and barbeque).

When creativity isn't a factor, giving a line cook at Chilis just as good a chance of winning as a Beard finalist, why would a great chef risk an established reputation?

We could think of a lot of reasons -- and we'd bet that Hosea Rosenberg, the winner of season five, could think of about 100,000 of them. Is there a local chef you'd like to see on Top Chef?

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

"When creativity isn't a factor, giving a line cook at Chilis just as good a chance of winning as a Beard finalist..."

This is how TC used to be.  Not everyone was a "real" chef.  So that element has been lost. Good and bad, I would say.  In any event, TC will probably never be able to top its LAs Vegas season.  Crappy Robyn notwithstanding.


Jenn Wolowitz!!!!


Troy Gaurd would be great on this show, and while he may be too well established for Top Chef some of his protege could compete and do quite well!  Jensen Cummings would rock on that show.  There is a chef named Cory Baker at Sushi Den, and though he is mainly a sushi chef he comes up with incredible hot and cold items for his Omakase's he would be great on that show.  That said should you ever want an adventerous and tasty journey through Japanese food get him to do your Omakase, you wont be dissapointed

Now Trending

From the Vault