Top

blog

Stories

 

Alonzo Ashley death: ACLU wants coroner's docs, possible changes in police Taser training

Thumbnail image for alonzo ashley.jpg
Alonzo Ashley.
The decision by Denver DA Mitch Morrissey not to charge anyone in the case of Alonzo Ashley, who died at the Denver Zoo after an incident involving police, has already stirred controversy. But the ACLU of Colorado also believes it raises doubts about police training regarding Tasers and the positioning of a suspect's body -- both of which may have contributed to Ashley's death.

As we've reported, the Denver Police Department -- whose account differs substantially from the one shared by the victim's family -- maintains that Ashley got into a heated argument with his girlfriend on a hot July day at the zoo. Shortly thereafter, he began acting irrationally and attacked a zoo security guard prior to the arrival of DPD officers. Ashley is said to have ignored their verbal commands to calm down, and when the cops tried to arrest him, he began biting, sinking his teeth into one cop and a zoo employee. One officer was also hit by the man, and another zoo staffer wound up with a head injury.

marvin booker protest flier photo large.jpg
Marvin Booker, who also died after being contact-tased.
At that point, Ashley was contact tased, as opposed to being struck by Taser barbs. What's the difference? DPD spokesman Sonny Jackson explained it to us this way: "A contact tasing is where you basically put the Taser against the skin -- and it only affects that area. It doesn't necessarily affect the whole body. The other one, the one with the barbs that you shoot, they can't stand, and you can't touch someone if it's been deployed. Whereas contact tasing works locally on the area being touched, so you can get the person to comply."

Not in this case. The DPD says Ashley kept fighting for several more minutes before he could finally be taken into custody. At that point, however, he began to convulse and his breathing stopped. He later died of a heart attack and respiratory arrest, according to the autopsy. But that's not all the report showed, according to Mark Silverstein, the local ACLU's legal director.

"It also revealed that there were five discharges of the police Taser, and the report says it was in the drive-stun mode" -- the technical term for contact tasing, as referred to DPD spokesman Jackson above. However, Silverstein believes such usage can be "really unfortunate and counterproductive," particularly in cases like this one.

"When the Taser is held up against the subject's body, it doesn't have that much-promoted paralyzing effect," he points out. "All it does is cause pain. And so, when you have an agitated subject who's displaying signs of being irrational and is resisting being handcuffed, causing him pain doesn't produce compliance. It causes thrashing and agitates him even more -- and that's the opposite effect of what the police officers would want."

For Silverstein, Ashley's tasing recalls the device's use on Marvin Booker, who died in law-enforcement custody in July 2010; charges weren't issued in this incident, either. And while there's no mention of Ashley having been put in a chokehold, as was done in Booker's case, the positioning of his body as police tried to get him under control troubles Silverstein.


My Voice Nation Help
6 comments
Kwenoir
Kwenoir

The problem with the Denver Police or any police is they first take a position of authority in tense situations.  You do not tell a person that is upset to calm down.  They may have a right to be upset.  First you acknowledge their upset and then offer to help.  Saying words like, "Hey guy, I know you are upset.  Let me help.  Whats going on?"  This is sooooooo simple.  Denver police are really untrained in situations.  I have encountered them a few times.  In every case, they try to flex and act big.  Just incase you need to be reminded, you are public servants.  I think it will be good if everyday you look in the mirror and remind yourselves.

stellarsjay
stellarsjay

DPD spokesman Jackson says a taser dart victim can't be touched- this is exactly opposite to claims that police are supposed to apply cuffs while the current is running- called "cuffing under power". You just mustn't put your hands on the body between the two darts. Sounds like Mr. Jackson's misleading the media to make pain compliance look better.

Wiki
Wiki

"Although the Taser [17] is a programmable device, the controlling software does not limit the number of the bursts of pulses and the time between bursts while the trigger is held down continuously, or the number of times the shock cycles can be repeated. Thus the design does not adequately reduce the likelihood that the victim's heart enters into a deadly ventricular fibrillation."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E...

HoriLori
HoriLori

The citizens of Denver need to understand that the DPD has the right to beat and even kill you should you not comply.  Just ask them, but make sure your health insurance is payed in full, you will more then likely need it if you are lucky enough to survive the adventure.

Dave David
Dave David

Is there any concern for the victims of this thug that killed himself?

Quadrophinc
Quadrophinc

no they were all gay cokeheads so nobody cares

Now Trending

Denver Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...