Occupy Denver: Charge against plaintiff in David Lane lawsuit dropped days before court date

Update by Michael Roberts: Earlier this month, attorney David Lane sent an open records request to the City of Denver regarding possible collusion with officials elsewhere in timing Occupy Denver crackdowns. The city claimed not to have any info, but today -- a week before a scheduled court date over an occupation-related temporary injunction request -- Lane plans to resubmit the request. Why?

The reason has to do with an e-mail sent on November 23 by Amber Miller, spokeswoman for Denver Mayor Michael Hancock, to Lane associate Christopher Dodd. Here it is:

Mr. Dodd -

When we replied to your records request by saying the Mayor's Office had no responsive records, we meant that the Mayor did not have "documentation of any... communication between Mayor Hancock (and/or his staff) and the governors or mayors of any other states or municipalities (and/or their staff) regarding the Occupy Movement." We were not withholding any document based upon an exemption from disclosure.

Admittedly, we had only searched for records of the Mayor -- we had not searched for records of the staff of the Mayor's office. We have now done so and have determined that neither the Mayor nor any member of his staff has any "documentation of any... communication between Mayor Hancock (and/or his staff) and the governors or mayors of any other states or municipalities (and/or their staff) regarding the Occupy Movement."

Please advise of additional questions or concerns regarding this request.

Best --

Amber Miller

Lane had assumed that Denver reps would have been more thorough in responding to the initial records request. "On the one hand, I give them credit for fessing up that they didn't do a full-blown search," he says. "On the other hand, I give them criticism for not doing a full-blown search."

Given this discrepancy, Lane and company will submit an expanded request just in case other things were overlooked.

In the meantime, a hearing over the injunction request has been set for 9 a.m. Monday, December 5, in the Federal District courtroom of Judge Robert Blackburn. According to Lane, "I want the judge to enjoin the City of Denver and its police department from ticketing people for honking in support of Occupy Denver, ticketing people who pull over to offer food, clothing or support, stop arresting people for being in the park after 11 p.m. and stop harassing and ticketing people for placing objects on the sidewalk."

Incidents that fall within these parameters continue to take place. Consider a brief police chase over a woman's attempt to make a donation on Thanksgiving. As such, Lane believes that "Denver police are absolutely retaliating against people because they don't like their First Amendment-protected speech.

"You can camp out on sidewalks or streets to get tickets for a musical show or a good deal on a sale. So when you're supporting capitalism by buying something, the police are your best friend. But if you're camping out in protest, they will do anything to harass you or anyone who wants to give you support -- and that's a First Amendment violation. Police don't get to pick and choose which messages they like and those people, and they don't get to pick and choose which messages they don't like and harass those people."

Look below to see a video version of the Thanksgiving story. Then page down to see our earlier coverage about the injunction and open-records requests.


My Voice Nation Help
59 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Jtcolfax
Jtcolfax

Things are getting interesting:  2 days before this court action happens, there will be a tea party counter demonstration against Occupy Denver.  The tea party is meeting at the State Capitol, Occupy Denver is just West of there on Broadway.  Let's see ONE tea partying get a ticket if they honk.  And there had better not be any tables!http://blogs.denverpost.com/th...

Michael Roberts
Michael Roberts

Love the post, J.T. Thanks.

Jtcolfax
Jtcolfax

Thanks.  Look at the occupy colorado springs facebook.  The organizers of the counter demonstration are just going nuts with the usual "denver homeless are being paid 5 dollars to be there"  etc.  This counter protest COULD be such an interesting chance for dialogue, but the buildup to it is already revealing it's going to be a freak show.  I have never worn a bandanna to Occupy Denver in my dozens of visits.  But this time I think I will.

debekniss
debekniss

Where have you heard about being paid to protest at Denver?

And I think if both parties did have a simple message which worked for both, this would be great I think. Occupy would show workablitiy and Tea Party could show some serious flexablity too. The Occupy is a peoples movement and the Tea Party is full of people. I will wish for the best because this will scare goverment even more lets see if the tea party gets pepper sprayed.

Janelle_smith
Janelle_smith

I assure you that if i decided to set up a tent in the middle of downtown it would not last long.  rules in society are set in place for a reason.  If there are no rules than it becomes anarchy. While I may not agree with this protest I do believe in the first amendment, go ahead and protest but follow the rules.  Otherwise it just becomes a fight between the protesters and cops and the message is lost.  Which is what is happening now.

Protest during the day and go home at night. oh wait... 99% of the protesters are homeless, jobless, and/or unemployable. Looking at the photo I just see a bunch of people sitting around eating free food and playing guitars(with an anarchy symbol on the tent, very mature) Asking for donations of things I work hard to earn.  really productive, if you want change use the voice you were given and get involved in the community, Ex: Vote, support small businesses, create a new form of media, etc...

DebeKniss
DebeKniss

I see the tents more sumbolic as a sign would be. So if the Governor let them stay for how many wees before he cracked down with riot police shouldn't Hickenlooper also be blamed for allowing it so long? See he also broke the law in your words and in mine so anything regarding riot police after that fact was excessive force and undue harrassment on the Gov side. Now will he have to face the same charges as those arressted? He should he allowed it.

Sananda
Sananda

The Occupy movement is a very important step in the people of this country taking back control and not letting corporate America dictate laws and elect people to office who will support the business' agendas. That being said, I have no issue with business' being successful, providing they do it in a manner that is not invasive to the governments that are supposed to run "by the people and for the people".As John Kay (of the rock group Steppenwolf) said in one of their songs back during Vietnam...which ironically still applies today "There's a monster on the loose, it's got our heads into a noose...and it just sits there watching.". The song is Monster and it VERY much applies to today as it did back in the 70's.I also have another reference people might be interested in. There is a movie out called "Getto Physics" and it to deals with how the world is waking up to it's current situation.

debekniss
debekniss

I highly recomend the movie Inside Job 2010 it is a doc story on what the banks and such have done with our Governments help a must see for all who want to learn more why Occupy is protesting please check it out.

Gfl
Gfl

WHAT ABOUT MY RIGHT TO ENJOY MY CITY? My right to walk through the parks without feeling harassed and intimidated by protesters? I know the protesters don't think they are creating hostility in the city, but they are. It's not the police: it's the protesters.

Debekniss
Debekniss

Oh please I lived near that park and the only ones using it before the protest was dug dealers and drunks and this is your idea of a happy stroll through the park? Since Occupy has been protesting those elements have left. Hey you can buy your srufgs elsewehere no one is stopping you. And from reading many of your posts you just want to whine no one is stopping you from going there and enjoying it. That is all in your head.

ConcernedCitizen
ConcernedCitizen

You are safer now in that park than you were before Occupy Denver, when it was overrun with drug dealers.

debekniss
debekniss

hear hear and isn't it nice those folks have moved elsewhere? I think it is great !!!

Sananda
Sananda

It appears that you are not living in the same world as everyone else. I don't mean that in a mean spirited way, but looking around at what is going on in this country and around the world...taking a walk through a park is the least of your worries. Oh, by the way. There are many other parks in Denver if you REALLY feel threatened...or are you just looking for a reason to spout off?

Gfl
Gfl

 Sorry but I do not agree with you. I am fully aware of 'what is going on' and I guess we just perceive things differently. Why should I not be allowed to enjoy my city as it was intended? No offense, but who are you to say that walking in parks is the least of my worries? Parks are for the people to enjoy, NOT TO INHABIT and take over. It's gang mentality. If they really want to change things, this is not the way to go about it.

debekniss
debekniss

Well the protesters are people and they are enjoying it. And no I don't think you understand it all or you would not be whining about it. How many times did you go to those parks before the protests began? Didn't the drug dealers make you feel uncomfortable?

Nancy Nixon
Nancy Nixon

In response to Elizabeth Vitale: PLEASE don't reproduce!In Thanks to David Lane, defender of the Constitution of the United States of America:DAVID LANE FOR GOVERNOR!

debekniss
debekniss

At this point he could very well win and it would be wonderful to get Hickenlooper out of there. God Forbid there is a real problem after the weak leadership skills Hickenlooper has shown us.

coloradojohn
coloradojohn

Occupy Denver needs a Wiki Leak inside the city and state government. Come on you guys just a simple USB drive with some emails. No biggie to do!

JJ
JJ

Even before the bonus army, tents were crucial in protest right here in Colorado. Occupy is hardly the first instance of protesters being attacked in their tents by this state. Perhaps Hickenlooper and Hancock should brush up on their history and refer to the Ludlow Massacre where 1200 miners and their families were attacked by the Colorado National Guard for striking against Rockefeller. Forced to set up a tent city due to evictions from their company owned houses.

debekniss
debekniss

.Rockefeller now there is a !% if ever there was one LOL

a reasonably sized hamburger
a reasonably sized hamburger

I would think that if money is free speech in the form of commercials, advertisements, then anything else money buys is free speech.  A tent is free speech.  The Supreme Court wants one dollar = one vote, that is what you are going to get.

Allbert
Allbert

Oh you forgot to add that the Supreme Court also said this year that donations (BRIBES) from business's are considered FREE SPEECH. I didn't see the word business having a First Amendment Rights, I only saw the word PEOPLE. The people who own the companies have a First Amendment right, but not the entire business itself. 

Guest
Guest

I agree but the pwers that be are a little shady on this form of thought lol

Mani
Mani

I really want to start an Occupy Rocky Mountain National Park. The Least time I pitched a Tent there it cost me 18 bucks a night. Who's with me????

kickdemout
kickdemout

“The “occupiers” are the post-digested remains of the natural journey through the intestinaltract of the metastasizing liberal ideology in education and pop culture”. - Derek Hunter

Whatever
Whatever

Derek Hunter is a post-digested-remains-head.

Occupy This!
Occupy This!

But, remember, at least some state agencies (like the Department of Revenue) don't consider email to be subject to a CORA request. The DOR said, wrt mmj, that they routinely destroyed all their email.http://blogs.westword.com/late...

Keith X
Keith X

I'd like to know why the Secret Federal Police aka DHS are not included in the list. Particularly since many of the "anti-terror" tactical training & weapons used have been paid for by DHS programs.

Bob Smith
Bob Smith

"The Governor's Office has no public records responsive to your request."

Obfuscatory bureaucratic bullshit.  Are there any "public servants" left anywhere who can simply tell the truth? Or have the lawyers castrated them all?

About what I expected from The Huckster.

Rob
Rob

The qualification regarding 'public' records seems to indicate that there's a bit of executive privelege being invoked here, IMO.  Wonder what 'private' records exist? 

Matt Rockwell
Matt Rockwell

All complaints against anyone in public office ought to be made public. When it is impossible to perform a check of your government's power and your government won't give you back the power to check it's service to it's citizens there is the potential for tyranny. Transparency is just as necessary to a functioning democracy as the vote. If our vote is based on truths with deception perpetrated by political leaders, our vote is a shame and democracy has disappeared. No crooks should be police, no crooks should be politicians, just like no school teachers. Corruption in government must be guarded against and transparency is the only possible solution. Take the power back. 

Nancy Lee Kaminski
Nancy Lee Kaminski

Wahoo, here we go to the next level. Thank the Goddess there are good guys with legal degrees. Support Occupy!

Webster
Webster

It's "Lawyer", not "Laywer."  Unless you meant the southern version.

elizabethvitale
elizabethvitale

all have to have legal suits brought against them. if they aren't true americans then get out of this country. they feed off of our hard labor, steal from us and lie against us... GET OUT OF THIS COUNTRY IF YOU AREN'T A TRUE AMERICAN... LEAVE

Sananda
Sananda

If your declaration was implemented, the NATIVE Americans ( I.e. the Indians) would be very happy I believe since they would have their original lands back. With statements like yours...you have to remember that ONLY the native Americans are TRUE AMERICANS! I further know that the original countries of OUR origin don't really want us back.

Rob
Rob

I read somewhere that dissent is the highest form of patriotism.  I believe that to my core.  Our nation's Founders did, too-that's why they carved out a special protection for speech in our Bill of Rights.  If you enjoy reading a newspaper, believe that you have a right to discuss political issues in common spaces owned by the public, and feel that government has an obligation to allow citizens to peaceably assemble in order to petition their government for a redress of grievances, you might just have more in common with the occupation than you think.  Solidarity and FREEDOM!

hooray!
hooray!

please tell your grandparents that we want our country back. you can leave too. i'll miss you so much.

Bandmanager007
Bandmanager007

Define "true American" for me please?  Cause as I see it.  It's different to different people.  But one thing for sure, our Consitution gives people the RIGHT to protest peacefully and this is not happening...so who is breaking the law here?   

Gfl
Gfl

 Nobody has the right to take over an entire city and call it a 'protest.' Get real.

Debekniss
Debekniss

Entire city? Where are you getting your information because it's wrong.

Allbert
Allbert

The states and the city governments are violating the Constitution. Which is the SUPREME LAW of our land..... And supersedes all city and state law with relation to Constitutional protections. And that's listed in the 14th Amendment sec. 1.

JohnSmith
JohnSmith

So, I guess you'll be on the first plane back to Italy. 

Arrivederci!

From the Vault

 

©2013 Denver Westword, LLC, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Denver / Boulder

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city