Kelli Lynn Murphy found guilty of killing her two kids on dead son's eleventh birthday

Original post, 6:42 a.m. November 15: Trial is underway in one of the most shocking cases of 2011 -- Castle Rock mom Kelli Lynn Murphy's alleged murder of her two elementary-school-age children. Among the revelations to emerge from early testimony: When police arrived at the tragic scene, Murphy's wrists had been cut.

As we reported last year, a suicidal Murphy called 911 at 7:48 a.m. on May 23, 2011, telling the operator that her kids -- Madigan, six, and Liam, nine -- "are in heaven right now." However, their bodies were in their respective beds. They were dead, but showed no signs of physical injury; the coroner later determined that they'd been asphyxiated.

kelli lynn murphy house.JPG
Now, we also know that Murphy told 911 she'd slit her wrists. According to 9News' trial coverage, one of the officers who responded to the scene had to hold paper towels over the wounds while quizzing her about the kids, who she said were "deceased."

In the days after her arrest, more details emerged about Murphy and her relationship with her husband, Robert Eric Murphy, who goes by his middle name.

At first glance, the family seemed happy. But according to court documents, troubles lurked just below the surface. The couple had filed for divorce, and Kelli took out a civil protection order against Eric in early March, telling frightening tales to back up this request.

madigan murphy.JPG
One one occasion, she said Madigan had been dawdling at the dinner table after Eric had finished eating. He allegedly responded by grabbed her throat and screaming at her to finish her meal. On another, he was giving Madigan a bath, and when the girl didn't wash the soap off her quickly enough by his standards, Kelli said he seized her by the neck and forced her head under the faucet. She also claimed Eric held her captive in the basement in addition to hitting her with the door.

liam murphy.jpg
Nonetheless, Kelli asked that the divorce petition be withdrawn on in April 2011; a meeting on the topic was scheduled for the days after Madigan and Liam's deaths. She also had a court appearance on the docket in regard to the restraining order.

The Sunday before the killings, Eric requested that Castle Rock police check on the welfare of the kids. Apparently, nothing was found amiss at that time -- but by the next morning, everything was.

Continue to read more about the start of Kelli Lynn Murphy's trial, including photos and videos.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
DonkeyHotay topcommenter

American Family Values.


I can't think of a single county where the 'Insanity' defense has been effective.

UNLESS, when defending law enforcement or politicians.

Patrick Sullivan CONTINUES to be an EXCELLENT example of this.


Parents, please have your children spayed or neutered before entering high school ....

Or attending church !!!


Poor Kelli!!!!! Her husband yelled at the kids! Even if you can believe anything this stupid woman says, she should have gotten the death penalty.

Legen Dairy
Legen Dairy

No because she's going to be a tax payers burden til she dies. Put me in a room with her. Hold her down and ill cover her with a pillow beating her with a orange filled sock til she dies.

DonkeyHotay topcommenter

Religion = Superstitious Nonsense for Ignorant Imbeciles.


@pat01 No death penalty .

I hope she lives to be 100 & is TORTURED by her actions everyday,

for the remainder of her miserable existence  !


 @DonkeyHotay  You are such a pathetic piece of shit. Get a job or a life or a friend, I don't know, just go the fuck away sad sack of shit. Nobody cares what you think. Get that through your thick fucking skull.

Now Trending

Denver Concert Tickets

From the Vault