Fetuses-aren't-people argument was "morally wrong," says Catholic hospital

Categories: News

Thumbnail image for catholic cover 114x130.jpg
Catholic Health Initiatives has acknowledged that it was "morally wrong" for its lawyers to argue in court that fetuses aren't people. As explained in our cover story "The Meaning of Life," the Englewood-based operator of 78 Catholic hospitals in seventeen states claimed that it couldn't be held liable for the deaths of two unborn babies who died at St. Thomas More Hospital in Canon City because "under Colorado law, a fetus is not a 'person.'"

The lawsuit was filed by a man named Jeremy Stodghill, who sued Catholic Health Initiatives and St. Thomas More Hospital for the wrongful death of his wife and unborn twin sons. His wife, Lori Stodghill, was 28 weeks pregnant when she died of a pulmonary embolism at St. Thomas More in 2006. Doctors decided not to do an emergency Cesarean section to try to save the babies -- which Jeremy believes was a terrible mistake.

jeremy stodghill 250x375.jpg
Jeremy Stodghill.
After learning of the case, Colorado's Catholic bishops announced they would "undertake a full review" of the lawsuit. "From the moment of conception, human beings are endowed with dignity and with fundamental rights," the bishops said in a statement.

Last week, the three bishops met with four Catholic Health Initiatives executives, including the organization's president and CEO, Kevin Lofton. Today, both the bishops and CHI issued statements, which are on view below.

"CHI representatives acknowledged that it was morally wrong for attorneys representing St. Thomas More Hospital to cite the state's Wrongful Death Act in defense of this lawsuit," Catholic Health Initiatives' statement says. "That law does not consider fetuses to be persons, which directly contradicts the moral teachings of the Church."

The organization also pledged to refrain from further arguments about Colorado's wrongful death law, which it says does not allow fetuses to sue. "Although the argument was legally correct," the statement says, "recourse to an unjust law was morally wrong."

For their part, the bishops said they "commend CHI for its rapid acknowledgement of this situation and its commitment to rectifying any harm it may have caused. We join CHI in affirming the fundamental truth that human life, human dignity, and human rights begin at conception. No law can ever mitigate God-given human rights."

jeremy stodghill tattoo 250x193.jpg
Stodghill has his sons' footprints tattooed on his chest.
Both statements also mention Catholic Health Initiatives' legal victories: "Two courts of law -- the Circuit Court in Fremont County and the Colorado Court of Appeals -- have supported the position of CHI and St. Thomas More Hospital that nothing done by doctors, nurses and other staff members would have changed this horrible outcome."

Stodghill has now appealed to the Colorado Supreme Court. If the high court were to hear the case, Catholic Health Initiatives says, "the Wrongful Death Act would not be among their considerations." Instead, it says, the main question is whether the hospital was negligent in caring for Lori Stodghill and her unborn twins. "The Circuit and Appellate courts have overwhelmingly concluded otherwise," Catholic Health Initiatives notes.

But Beth Krulewitch, one of Stodghill's attorneys, says that's not entirely true. "What I first and foremost asked the Supreme Court to do is to send the case back to the Court of Appeals to decide the issue of whether the Wrongful Death Act precludes this type of claim," she says. In other words, she'd like the appeals court to rule on whether a father such as Stodghill can sue for the wrongful death of his unborn babies.

Furthermore, she says Catholic Health Initiatives' statement that it has "never pursued a collection" of $47,000 in legal fees from Stodghill is also only partially true. While the hospital didn't ask to garnish Stodghill's wages, it did ask for legal fees. Once they were awarded, Krulewitch says, "the hospital came to us and said it would give up the $47,000 if Jeremy agreed not to appeal and we said, 'No, we're not going to do that.'"

When Krulewitch filed a motion asking the court to postpone the payment of those fees, she says Catholic Health Initiatives opposed it. Stodghill ended up declaring bankruptcy.

Continue to read the two statements.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
DonkeyHotay topcommenter

Morality and the Catholic Church in the same sentence ... ROTFLMAO !!


Say what it takes to win, say what it takes to position for the next round, say what it takes to make it go away, ....in a just society, Bishop's would not sound like lawyers.  

Do the words of the Bishops seem sincere to anyone?  

The Catholic Church and the Bishops can never even begin to understand our lives,  our world, and the damage they do, when they exist, operate and preach in the moral vacuum between word and deed. 

BackOffImStarving topcommenter

Morally-wrong like taking more than two lollipops from the bank teller, or morally-wrong like covering up years and years of sexual abuse committed by the clergy?

DonkeyHotay topcommenter

@slcutah ... there is a reason why Jesuit became a synonym for Liar in the English language.


@BackOffImStarving@DonkeyHotay  Looks like the nuns, the religious orders that sponsor CHI, the Sisters of Mercy and Sisters of Charity were familiar names to those who suffered in the Magdalene Laundries. 

....For their perceived sins, they were forced to perform unpaid labor for the commercial benefit of four Irish orders of nuns. 

Abuse by Church and State: The Hidden Story of Ireland’s Magdalene Laundries


@BackOffImStarving@DonkeyHotay     Thanks for the link. wow. The Jesuits, Colorado Bishops and CHI appear to be mere pikers compared to Catholic nuns...?  There are headlines around the world.....
UN panel urges Ireland to probe Catholic torture

Human rights groups say young women were abused after being sent to the so-called Magdalene Laundries.
and yesterday, Mon Feb 4, 2013: Report says government was directly involved in sending girls and woman to work in slave-like conditions in laundries run by Catholic orders.(nuns)....

Maybe the Bishops do know what they are doing. Thanks to the Catholic Church's continuing history of institutionalized "charity", there are opportunities for the Stoghill's to work off legal and court costs the Catholic Health System sought and won here in Colorado. 

Thanks for the info BackoffImStarving....but it makes my heart hurt realizing  this situation and that the Bishop's response was not rock bottom...just another day for those who wear the pointy hats...

Now Trending

Denver Concert Tickets

From the Vault