Death penalty battle heats up at the State Capitol

Categories: News, Politics

lethal injection 205x205.jpg
In more than eight hours of emotional testimony that stretched well into the evening, activists and faith groups seeking to abolish the death penalty in Colorado squared off against prosecutors and other backers of the ultimate punishment yesterday -- with family members of homicide victims speaking out on both sides, calling the process of execution a "nightmare" and a "tremendous burden" for victims' families, but also essential to the pursuit of justice.

At issue is House Bill 13-1264, an effort to repeal capital punishment in the state, sponsored by representatives Claire Levy of Boulder and Jovan Melton of Aurora and now under review by the House Judiciary Committee. Democratic lawmakers came within one vote of euthanizing Colorado's largely moribund death penalty four years ago and believe they now have the momentum to succeed, despite last summer's Aurora theater shootings and other high-profile rampages that have reignited debate over capital punishment. Six states have abolished the death penalty in the last six years, including Maryland's action last week, bringing to seventeen the number of states that have banned the practice.

Claire Levy 205x205.jpg
Claire Levy.
Although the death penalty has been imposed in seventeen cases since it was reinstated in Colorado in 1978, it's only been carried out once -- against Gary Davis in 1997. Levy's opening remarks focused on the millions spent by the state prosecuting and defending capital cases through decades of appeals, the emotional toll on victims' families, and the risk of executing an innocent defendant. (Nationally, 142 inmates sentenced to death have been exonerated over the past four decades, and in 2011, former Governor Bill Ritter issued a posthumous pardon for Colorado's own Joe Arridy, a mentally impaired man wrongfully convicted and executed in the 1930s.)

"Will Colorado have executed someone the Supreme Court will one day say should not have been executed?" Levy asked.

Jovan Melton 205x205.jpg
Jovan Melton.
Melton cited studies that suggest the death penalty doesn't deter crime and is applied in a racially biased way. All three of the men currently on Colorado's death row -- Nathan Dunlap, Robert Ray and Sir Mario Owens -- are African-Americans from his district, Melton pointed out.

In the hours of riveting testimony about the bill that followed, both sides brought out their big guns, starting with Bob Autobee, whose son, Eric, was murdered by inmate Edward Montour at the Limon prison in 2002. Autobee and his wife renounced the effort to execute Montour last year after a decade of frustrating delays and setbacks. "The system doesn't really work," Autobee told the committee. "It has been a nightmare.... Our case is the poster child for this."

Other family members of homicide victims talked about the arbitrary nature of prosecutors' decision to pursue the death penalty or not, the fear of going through endless appeals if the case went capital -- and suggested the vast sums spent on the state's death process could be better applied to victim services and cold cases.

Continue for more about the death penalty battle at the State Capitol.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
davebarnes topcommenter

I don't understand the debate.

Put it before the voters.

They will vote to keep the death penalty.

James Holmes, Nathan Dunlap, Sir Mario Owens, Austin Sigg, Dexter Lewis, Joseph Hill, Lynell Hill will ensure that voters remain angry.

Anyone who thinks this a rational argument is a fucking idiot.

DonkeyHotay topcommenter

Death is NOT a Penalty.

Death ENDS suffering and pain.

Ipso facto.


The greatest gift we have is life. To take it away, is, by definiton, the worst of sanctions.

There is a reason nearly all murderers, subject to the death penalty, do everything they can to escape it.


Life is the greates of gifts, thereby the sanction of death is the most severe.

Nearly all murderers subject to the death penalty do all they can to avoid it.


@DonkeyHotay  My point totally . You need only a G.E.D. to be employed by the Dept of Corrections . My BIGGEST issue falls into being under the control of someone far less intelligent than myself .


@DonkeyHotay @davebarnes  Biblically, we all die because of our sins. As that is God's rule, I think that answeres that question.

In addition,

-- God/Jesus: ‘Honor your father and your mother,’ and ‘Whoever curses father or mother must certainly be put to death.’ Matthew 15:4

This is a New Testament command, which references several of the same commands from God, in the same circumstance, from the OT.

davebarnes topcommenter


But, Colorado Christians will vote overwhelmingly to execute people.

Now Trending

Denver Concert Tickets

From the Vault