Horse cruelty trial: Was toxic weed responsible for sickening animals?

Categories: News

little big man 205x205.jpg
Big photos below.
Update: This morning I spoke by phone with Randall Hatlee, one of the two ranchers found not guilty on misdemeanor animal neglect charges in the much-scrutinized Park County case involving several ailing horses, described in my original post below.

While Hatlee expressed some frustration with the investigation he and Ronald Swift went through, he also wanted to warn others about the toxic weed that he believes sickened his horses.

"We were falsely accused of a lot of things," says Hatlee. "It was a hard thing for us. We're still looking for answers."

hoary alyssum.jpg
Hoary Alyssum.
Although animal control officers temporarily removed seven emaciated horses from the Echo Valley Ranch, even Hatlee's accusers concede that there were numerous other horses on the property that appeared to be well cared for. Hatlee says the ailing horses were also well-fed, but were younger and may have not had the same resistance to illness. "Those horses were definitely sick," he says. "As close as we can tell, they got sick with a toxic poisoning."

Hatlee suspects the culprit was hoary alyssum, a weed that has flourished on his ranch in recent drought conditions: "We've lost two-thirds of our pasture land because this weed is so prominent. We will be spraying for the next three years."

He and Swift were in the process of figuring out the safest way to transport the sickest horses to Colorado State University for testing, he adds, when Park County officers seized the group -- and incurred $8,000 in vet bills for treatment that a judge later ruled must be paid by the county, not the ranchers.

Continue for my previous coverage of this story.

Original post, 8:50 a.m. March 5: In a case that's been closely watched by animal-rights activists and has bitterly divided some elements of the local community, a Park County jury has found Randall Hatlee and Ronald Swift not guilty of misdemeanor animal-cruelty charges more than a year after seven emaciated horses were seized from Echo Valley Ranch near Bailey and one died of a bacterial infection.

Authorities said the horses showed obvious signs of neglect, and some, including Little Big Man (pictured below), were so weak they could hardly rise without assistance.But a judge later ordered all but one of the horses, which had gained weight substantially while in foster care, returned to Swift and Hatlee.

6 little big man.jpg
Little Big Man.
According to this account in the Park County Republican & Fairplay Flume, 11th Judicial District Attorney Thom LeDoux summed up his case by stressing experts' testimony on the poor condition of the seized animals and showing photos documenting how the horses improved under others' care. But defense attorney Darrell Campbell insisted his clients had been properly watering and feeding the horses and suggested that consumption of toxic weeds might have been a factor in their deterioration.

Hatlee and Swift, Campbell told the jury, "have a passion for their horses."

Gene Ferraro, a retired corporate investigator who followed the trial, which concluded late last week, told Westword he was surprised by the verdict. "Animal-abuse cases are tough to prove beyond a reasonable doubt," he notes. "This one was particularly difficult, because there were other horses on the property that appeared to be doing quite well."

Ferraro adopted one horse from Echo Valley who'd been found in a stall covered in feces, suffering from pressure sores and too weak to stand. "While there could have been doubt about what caused his condition, I believe the owners did have a duty to seek help for him and the other horses, and they didn't do that," he says.

Continue for our previous coverage of the Little Big Man case, including more photos.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

Whether children or horses - bottom line is who oversees their care has a responsibility. Whatever caused the debilitated state of these horses, they needed help which arrived almost too late. To find horses in such conditions is disheartening as help is available, one just has to ask, in due time. In our society it has become a pattern to dismiss responsibility and milk the system which is too weak to protect the innocent.That is why these cases happen - those who try to help get criminalized and chastised for trying to do the right thing. It's a system which has loop holes. With such hazardous weeds growing in a big equine community, Hatlee and Swift ought to focus on starting a committee of weed control to prevent more such cases and warn others. I am sure since the weed grew so abundantly on their property, it is growing on many other pastures too. Were there other cases of such toxic ingestions of weeds in Park County ? I would assume so. It's a terrible thing to having such a threat growing on your lands... so I hope they try their best to help other residents prevent such horror to their horses as they seem to be weed experts now.


Those horses were so obviously starved and neglected, and that those losers, Hatlee and Swift, would try to blame these poor animals condition on a "weed" is beyond ridiculous. They obviously didn't care about these horses and anyone who tries to spin that lame story is either scared of retaliation by them, or totally ignorant. The fact that these rednecks were found innocent is a complete travesty of justice. My only hope is that Karma bites them in the a** real hard...and soon too.


The vet mentioned by Monika never looked at these horses and said they were okay.  Too bad she repeats unfounded rumors instead of fact.


Donkey, that's the best you have?  Really there are children in worse condition? Starving and can't stand up? Where? Why haven't you done anything to help them, as the equine rescue people did in this instance? Are you a friend of the Swift's or Hatlees? Or maybe actually one of them with this asinine moniker (pun intended)? Or do you really believe its OK to  starve those that are  your responsibility? Pathetic comment.

DonkeyHotay topcommenter

There are human children in worse condition than this ... and social services does nothing to protect them.

Now Trending

Denver Concert Tickets

From the Vault