Medical marijuana from Colorado illegal in Kansas, court rules: More fuel for profiling?
Several of our posts about alleged profiling of cars from Colorado due to the state's marijuana laws have focused on Kansas. One involved Westword contributor Britt Chester, who was rousted there during a cross-country trip -- and another featured a Kansas attorney who encouraged Coloradans to ditch their weed before driving over the border.
One more incentive to do so? A court ruling establishing that Colorado medical marijuana remains illegal in Kansas. Details and the complete ruling below.
The case, heard by the Kansas Court of Appeals, which released its ruling on Friday, is officially entitled State of Kansas v. Troy James Cooper.
The decision was written by Judge G. Gordon Atcheson. Here's how he synopsizes the facts of the case:
As a resident of Colorado, Cooper lawfully obtained medical marijuana there. Cooper came to Kansas with his medical marijuana and intended to stay here for several weeks visiting family and friends before returning to Colorado. A law enforcement officer stopped Cooper in Ellsworth County and found him to have the prescribed medical marijuana. The State charged Cooper with simple possession of marijuana, a misdemeanor.... The district court acquitted Cooper on the grounds the prosecution contravened protections afforded him under the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and impermissibly interfered with his constitutional right to interstate travel.
|Judge G. Gordon Atcheson.|
In his view, the answer to this question "must be in the negative."
Atcheson acknowledges that "legalized medical marijuana is becoming more prevalent" not only in Colorado but elsewhere, pointing out that "according to one clearinghouse, eighteen states and the District of Columbia have authorized the use of marijuana for medical purposes.... As more states permit the use of medical marijuana, more people may be traveling through Kansas with their medication."
After weighing rulings in previous rulings seen as related to this one, the court determines that "the Privilege or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment does not bar the enforcement of Kansas criminal statutes prohibiting possession of marijuana against someone traveling through or staying temporarily in this state even though the individual possesses the marijuana in conformity with another state's law allowing its use and possession for medical purposes. In those circumstances, the right to lawfully possess the marijuana rests on state law and, therefore, is outside the scope of the Clause."
In his opinion, Atcheson stresses that the ruling is "a narrow one had has nothing to say about other constitutional grounds that might bar such prosecution," adding, "We...express no opinion on other constitutional rights or protections that conceivably might afford a defense to a person prosecuted under the Kansas Criminal Code for possessing marijuana obtained legally through another state's laws permitting its use as medication."
In other words, the court doesn't preclude the possibility of another argument against such an arrest being upheld. But the judges didn't buy this one.
Continue for more about Colorado medical marijuana in Kansas, including the court's ruling.