Nathan Dunlap clemency backers cite broad support as calls for death continue

Categories: News

More photos below.
The campaign to either save Nathan Dunlap from the death penalty or execute the man convicted of four brutal murders at a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant in 1993 has turned into something of a public-relations competition. As the Arapahoe District Attorney's Office continues to dole out statements from victims and associates who believe he deserves the ultimate punishment, Dunlap's advocates are working to humanize him even as they emphasize broad support for Governor John Hickenlooper to alter his sentence to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

On December 14, 1993, as we've reported, Dunlap entered the restaurant, from which he'd previously been fired, and shot five employees: Margaret Kohlberg, fifty, Sylvia Crowell, nineteen, Ben Grant and Colleen O'Conner, both seventeen, and Bobby Stephens, twenty. Only Stephens survived, and he was very seriously wounded.

The scene of the crime.
Dunlap was captured within hours and convicted in 1996, at which point the jury opted for execution. He's been on death row ever since, and earlier this month, a week was scheduled for the completion of the sentence: August 18-24.

Now, the only thing that will prevent the carrying out of this action is a grant of clemency from Hickenlooper -- and shortly after the date-setting, Dunlap backers and death-penalty foes combined forces to formally ask that the governor do so.

In the weeks since then, the office of Arapahoe County DA George Brauchler has been steadily releasing statements arguing the opposite point. Those represented thus far include a Chuck E. Cheese worker who was supposed to have worked that evening but took the night off to babysit and the mother of Ben Grant, who begs Hickenlooper to "sit back, make no decision, allow the one that twelve people made after listening to all the evidence seventeen years ago stand.

Ben Grant.
"I wish you could have met my son, listened to all of the things said about him after this act of planned murder, the amount of love that flowed," she added. "I honestly think if (you) had been there, you would have no doubt the decision for death."

The latest person to weigh in? An unnamed juror who hasn't changed his or her mind about the verdict.

"I have lived with this for a long time," the death-penalty-backing juror's statement begins. "My feelings are if one person [Hickenlooper] has the ability to change what a juror declares, then why do we need a jury? The only reason why anybody should be able to overturn what a jury's verdict declares is because of fraud, cheating or some other injustice. As for those three jurors who all of a sudden changed there minds, I doubt it."

Actually, there's plenty of evidence showing that three of those on Dunlap's jury have a new viewpoint on the matter. The trio signed affidavits saying that had they known Dunlap suffered from serious and undiagnosed mental illness at the time of the killings (he only started receiving Lithium treatments in 2006), they wouldn't have voted for death. See one of the affidavits below, along with other documents supporting clemency -- not just a reply to DA Brauchler's arguments in favor of execution, but a letter from the Colorado Criminal Defense Bar and a narrative of Dunlap's abuse-filled upbringing featuring photos like this....
...and this:
Madeline Cohen, an assistant federal public defender working on Dunlap's behalf, stresses that such material only scratches the surface of the support for clemency.

Continue for more about the clemency bid for Nathan Dunlap, including photos and documents.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

WW forgot to change Dunlap photos .

It's the 'Angelic' smile's, turn ......


Has WW FINALLY taken a position in this matter ?


Why should he get to live, his victims didn't..... He's had many years to think about what he's done and now it's time for him to man up and take his punishment...


Since it's Friday, will we have the 'scary' image all weekend ?

Then use the 'happy' one every other Sat & Sun,  til August .

Will your minds be made up anytime before ...... ?

Life W/O is far more of a punishment than being 'released' via a 'chair',  to the applause of a small crowd w/ I'm sure, Carole Chambers either 'hitting' the 'Switch' or at the VERY least, 'STANDING up FRONT ROW W/ a BULL-HORN !

DonkeyHotay topcommenter

Remember kids -- Death is NOT a Penalty ... death ENDS suffering.


Scary photo, Angelic photo, Scary photo,  ect ...

Just be sure to rotate images each day as you've been doing .

Will you ever ultimately chose a side or will you remain waiting on the 'majority' ?

I wish Hotay had a 'Wrist-Rocket' & knocked you off the ' fence of choice'. ......

DonkeyHotay topcommenter

@Green_eyes ... so you support killing people ... to show them that killing is wrong?

Does that include members of the U$ military who took part in the illegal attack, invasion and occupation of Iraq, slaughtering 100,000+ innocent Iraqi civilians -- women and children -- in the process?

Isn't it time for those killers to "man up and take their punishment" ?


@DonkeyHotay @Juan_Leg The both of you are right. The prisoner does not suffer the longevity of incarceration and receives legislative v. natural death. However the victims suffering remains even after death of criminal. True Brothers in Arms...



"It does ? Really ? So if my foster 'Daddy'. who is constantly beating my brothers or raping my sisters and I, were to die, the suffering would end ?"

"What about the twenty-years in prison, on Death Row, waiting to be executed for killing him ?"

"That sound WAY worse !!!"

Blood- Lust = Peace for Dunlap following nearly a 20 yr wait .....

DonkeyHotay topcommenter

@Juan_Leg ... I loved my Wrist-Rocket !!


@DonkeyHotay Eeezzz now, I know Green-eyes is an ass, don't let that one distract you. Soldiers are under orders. And even when they follow orders some of them get sent to Leavenworth. Your spirit is in the right place soldier, on the battlefield we could ya know GE, give GE the green light.Ha!jj


@DonkeyHotay   Should we begin addressing you,  'Hotay the Great' oi 'The Great Hotay', now that WW has made you famous w/ the 'Red-Star' & your very own article from the editor ?

Uh, still waiting on the signed 'hoof-print' .

Not to be pushy or anything .....

Now Trending

Denver Concert Tickets

From the Vault